1) Story: GotG (Force Awakens is too much of a rehash)
2) Special effects: Force Awakens, especially some of those practical bits
3) Interesting characters: GotG, but it was close.
4) Better acting: Force Awakens, but also close.
5) Funnier jokes: GotG
6) Surprises: Force Awakens
7) Leaving you with a better feeling of satisfaction after seeing it: GotG (once again Force Awakens's story hurt it)
8) Which of the two are you looking forward for it's sequel: Force Awakens.