By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

No "they were both good" option?

Both movies were good. Competent, well made science fiction action adventures. Both have some plot holes, some leaps in logic, and sacrifice some character for some more action. I wouldn't call either the second coming of sci-fi film making, or timeless classics, but they are both fun, popcorn eating action flicks.

Oddly enough, Guardians did a better job establishing the political landscape, despite that being something Star Wars has typically excelled in.