2007 was the best xbox line up ever.

[Azzanation]

OneKartVita said:

Azzanation said:

Your comparing Sales and reviews. I am comparing brand power. Mass Effect, Bioshock, Beutiful Katamari, Lost Oddesy and Blue Dragon were new IPs  no one new about them so how does a new IP have a big selling name? It doesnt until its released and reviewed. This recent holiday line-up holds names that people already know about. The Halo, Forza, Gears, TR Reboot names have become the house hold names in gaming. Everyone knows what Forza is where as PGR fails in comparison as an example.

Dont get me wrong, 2007 was a great year in gaming for Xbox aswell however interms of franchises releasing togother, 2015 has it beat.

I am curious to know why you mention Blue Dragon, Lost Odyssy and Beutiful Katamari when those games did not sell well and had average reviews. Were you trying to strenghten your argument there?

I'm sorry but you couldnt be more wrong.  

 

Brand power?  

 

I just said halo 3 in 2007 outsold all the Exclusives in 2015 combined.  

 

The brand power of the 2007 games are much bigger. 

 

Yeah tomb raider is big,  just not on xbox.  

Forza isn't anything special anymore.  

Halo has seen a huge decline.  

 

As I said it's no longer a debate.  2007 wins by any metric so you can't cherry pick one to suit your argument.  

You clearly are missing the point. Your still basing your arguments off sales and reviews. The fact mediocre Japanese exclusives were brought up clearly shows desperation here because they did poorly on all charts.

2015 housed the Biggest Xbox games in its history all at the same time where in other years that's never happened.

I am not arguing against the scores, all these games are great but we are talking best line-up NOT best games.