Overall it's FFX for me.
The characters, battle system, world and story all gelled with me and were very impressive for the time. The side-quests and Blitzball were superior to those found in XII which I found to be repetitive. It was also heavily story focussed (and linear) but balanced it with interesting side-quests and late-game content.
I fully acknowledge however that XII's story, setting and characters generally had more depth to them. Vaan and Penelo felt irritatingly out of place the further I played however, and essentially stopped me from caring about the storyline. I liked the fact it was open world but the content within the game was too repetitive. Without the story and characters to keep me going I eventually got bored of the game, and just didn't bother with the late/post-game material.








