By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
theprof00 on 28 October 2015
Edit Thread
zero129 said:
theprof00 said:
zero129 said:
theprof00 said:
theprof00 said:

You say you believed xander was the cop, and so that's why you protected him.
Why would you ask the cop to scan himself?

I'm going to quote this until you answer it.

Clearly when i said that it was before spurges lynch and you know it, so why your asking me this question is beyond me. i didnt even believe that the was a cop until after spurge was lynched, since you claimed to be the watcher i figured the is no way the would also be a cop. Clearly after spurges lynch it became clear to me your role claim was fake and the really was a cop, and with Xanter saying "Who wants the boss" i thought he was the cop and scanned spurge and thought spurge was mafia big boss since the miller shows as being such once scanned.

Except you said

"If spurge flips what he said=miller, doc protect prof, prof watch me, I protect myself, cop scan Xander or platina".

Look you keep dancing around my questions and you also keep trying to push the same silly questions on me that has been answered. If people cant see you as mafia i honestly just do not know what to say.

You can clearly see what i said and i can even go back and show you the post where i say (If the even is a cop) and i also explained about what we do if the isnt a cop..

You said that last night you thought xander was the cop. You thought this because spurge was the miller:
"Ok fuck it lets just lynch one one of the lurkers, if they turn out to be mafia and once prof watchs me tonight that will confirm me as town in his eyes, and the cop can then claim his role tomorrow if the cop claims we know spurge is telling the truth as long as we dont get a counter claim and then we can look into Axum or Outlaw but imo the cop should scan one of them anyways since it would help things!."

Spurge being the miller confirmed to you that a cop existed. And rightfully so, as you said:
"Personally imo if he keeps acting like this i think we should just lynch him now since it will pretty much confirm if we do have a town cop and then we can direct the town cop without him having to out himself until day 4 to get the last mafia member."

Yet, you said,:
"If the is a town cop you should scan Platina or Xanter"

In your own words, a town cop existing could be proven by spurge flipping miller.
"If spurge flips what he said miller =
Doc protect prof, prof watch me, I protect myself, cop (If the is one) scan Xantar or platina your choice."

So, in very simple english, you believed there was a cop, xander, as evidenced by your post that you protected xander because his "big boss" comment clued you in.
Yet, when acknowledging the potential existence of the cop, you said he should investigate xander.


Now then, you also stated:
"once prof watchs me tonight that will confirm me as town in his eyes"

So, you agree that I could've confirmed you.

So what I am left with, in this pile of garbage, is that instead of you following a plan that everyone in town agreed to, that would've cleared you as town to me (and the rest of town, mind you), you instead decided to protect a person who in your own words should be investigated by the cop.

Your reasoning for this is:
"i didnt even believe that the was a cop until after spurge was lynched"

Yet, you agreed yesterday, before the lynch, that if spurge flips miller and the cop exists, then he should cop xander, and doc should protect prof.

It's very clear that conditionally upon spurge's miller claim being true, you wanted xander investigated, but now you believed xander was the cop. This is called a contradiction. You are rewriting history in order to give yourself a reason to not be at your own home last night.