| zero129 said: Just for everyones information!. My main suspicions about the prof are as follows HE claimed he was protected on night 2 He claimed it was the doc that protected him after i claimed town bodyguard and told him i didnt protect him Both people who became suspicious of him has ended up being dead and both where town. up till this point he was not very active at all, but he explained that he had his reasons for that with breaking up with his gf so this could be true. He only placed a vote on me after i started saying id look into his reasons for voting for cone with the excuse that it was cos i said to xanter "I want big boss" . Im just putting it here so people can see the main points. Now the only thing is if he is telling the truth about being protected by the doc then he cant be mafia. But whats the chances of a town Doc being in this game too?? Now his character having psychic ability would also kinda line up with being a watcher. Id really like for some others to say what they think here. But for now im off to bed its 4:33am and i have to be up at 8 tomorrow x_x 3 hour sleep  . |
I'm just going to respond to this, but I agree, not happy that despite the explosion of posts between you and myself, there has been no increased activity from other players...
Anyway,
1. Just to correct you, I said I was protected on night 1, not night 2 as you wrote above.
2. I claimed that the doc protected me night one because I was counterclaiming you. I didn't believe you were a bodyguard, so I gave the best evidence I had, which was that I saw the doc. I believed you had made your role up, so I tried to get more info out of you, to which you replied that your bodyguard ability can protect yourself, which is something a bodyguard shouldn't be able to do. This confirmed to me that you had indeed made up your role, and hadn't checked the wiki thoroughly enough to make it believable. While I would expect a scum player with some experience to be very cautious about making sure the role sounded perfect, I would not put it past you to make some mistakes. This is not shit-talking, you honestly do not pay much attention...like the night 2 comment above. (i could give you a list of other errors you've made if you need further proof). Basically, I didn't believe your role, so i counterclaimed, and your response lead me to believe that i was right to doubt your role, because it looked made up.
3. You say that both players who suspected me ended up dead. However, you also swear that I am mafia. For whatever reason you seem to not think I'm sk. (my own theory is that is because you are the sk). However, both of those players who you're pointing at, have had sk flavor deaths (flames). So logically, i'd have to be SK to fit your theory that I killed them. You can't say I'm mafia, and then accuse me of SK flavor deaths. Furthermore, mario only ever made a passing suspicion about me, and unless I'm mistaken, cone never said anything to suspect me at all, though you swear he did with the comment about genders. Moreover, Cone had a killing role, and if he suspected me, he could have just tried to kill me. So, I disagree. Spurge on the other hand, has made comments suspecting me almost every day, yet spurge is not dead. This point you've made doesn't really hold up to scrutiny.
4. I voted for you because of the big boss comment. I had not even read the part where you said you'd look into my reasons for cone. I was catching up with the thread and that post of yours jumped out at me. I didn't bother reading the whole thing before posting. You writing that right before my post was simple coincidence.
