Was the original Xbox the best Microsoft console?

[Mr Puggsly]

Angelv577 said:

Mr Puggsly said:

Angelv577 said:

Mr Puggsly said:

I think we've gone full circle to my first response. "Depends on your preference."

We are already at a point two years in where there are many great titles avaialble on X1 but not 360. Some games on X1 were ported to 360 but are vastly inferior.

When it comes to JRPGs, 360 might have an edge. But the X1 is going to have some JRPGs as well, a few of them will have Final Fantasy in the title. Dragonscale could be a notable JRPG. Dark Souls III is coming. In my opinion MGSV does plenty to satisfy JRPG fans.

It seems MMO's and MOBA's are finding more success on X1. Those are a genres that never really found a significant audience on the 360. So again, I don't think either platform will have an objectvely better library. Even if X1 fails to please JPRG like 360 did, X1 may please audiences in genres the 360 failed at.

Let leave it on "Depends on preference" after all that's how the whole thread started, someone making an opinion.  It's still too early anyway to figure out how large is the xb1 library gonna be.

Were talking quanity now? 360 will likely win in most physical releases. But most of that is hot garbage.

No neccesarily but it can make the comparison more fair IMO.  for example, xb360 ended up with 3 mainline gears of war, at this rate we might see 2 mainline gears of war at the end of this gen.  I might be wrong but GOW 4 is bound to launched at the end of its third year.  Same with halo, we might see 2 mainline halo game but don't think xb1 is gonna match the same amount of spin off titles 360 had.  Racing genre.  Even though the amount of forza might end up equal, being longer on the market opened up the oportunity to release PGR to cover some years on the xb360 life.  I'm not sure we gonna see a PGR game this gen.  In most of the genres will be like that, xb360 had more of what xb1 is gonna end up having.

Well X1 already has MCC, most of the Halo games on 360 are already better on X1. Halo 5, 6, and Wars 2 are the titles certainly coming to X1. I wouldn't be surprised if we see more as well.

Gears Ultimate is on X1 and a superior experience, perhaps the previous games will get the same treatment down the road. Gears 4, 5 and 6 could be on X1.

If they do a Forza every year there will be more Forza games on X1 than Fozra and PGR combined on the 360. There were six Forza and PGR games combined on 360. We don't need PGR, hopefully Playground games keeps making Forza games because the Horizona games are fantastic.

Again, you're focusing on quantity. What X1 is getting will be trump most of 360's library in quality.

Ultimately, I'm gonna keep my 360 and PS3 because they have some cool stuff we aren't gonna see on their successors.