I'm one of the skinniest guys my friends know, and due to my strong legs (hidden mass), almost no fat content (seriously, I'm pretty slender) and still hit the gym up regularly, my weight to height ratio suggests I'm in danger of being "overweight" (BMI).
Overweight is such a silly term to begin with. Unhealthily "Fat" is a better term, but much harder to calculate than "weight".
Numbers: Checker Players > Halo Players
Checkers Age and replayability > Halo Age and replayability
Therefore, Checkers > Halo
So, Checkers is a better game than Halo.