Wii Fit calls young girl overweight, girl is devastated - I blame Wii Fit!

[Nintendo Zealot]

famousringo said:

PooperScooper said:
Thats what I was thinking stof. Biased parents man. Or maybe her parents are whales and the kid is healthy comparably to them

Or she's very active and has more muscle than most girls her age. Or she's short and stocky.

BMI is a quick-and-dirty measurement of healthy weight. Its main feature is convenience and simplicity, not accuracy. All of this is fine... until people start to take it too seriously.

How many overly muscular 10 year old girls do you know? I say she is fat.