Gears of War Ultimate Edition Review Thread - Meta 82

[Mr Puggsly]

the-pi-guy said:

Mr Puggsly said:

Sorry, your examples are just nit picking. A few graphical hitches and him sucking at multiplayer arent good excuses for a low score.

He gave Driveclub a 2/5 and people said bullcrap. However, a lot of critics didnt love Driveclub.

With Gears Ultimate, Jeff is the only critic thus far that flatout disliked it.

Frankly, people like you are ignoring all the positive reviews and using the negative as gospel.

If they were a big deal to him, that's his opinion.  You're the one who is trying to belittle someone's opinion by suggesting that they shouldn't have reviewed the game.  I'm trying to explain that EVERY REVIEW IS VALID.  Every one has their own opinion, there is no wrong opinion.  If he feels the game was deserving of the 4/10 score, that's his opinion.  Would I agree with it?  Probably not, everyone else seems to be very much enjoying the game.  

You're the one trying to explain away 1 bad review, and instead of understanding that everyone can have their opinion.  

Accept that people can have an opinion that isn't wrong and their opinion isn't driven by being a fanboy.  Everyone might love a game, and everyone might hate the game.  That's their opinion, their experience.  

I'm not using the negative as gospel, I am merely defending the review.  

Why am I doing that?  

Because as the reviewer, it is his opinion.  Don't need to bash someone just because you don't agree with their opinion.  Respect every single review, as it is someone's opinion.  

Nope, I dont respect his review. And I respect people even less that use that review as proof this is a bad game.

Anyhow, Im done arguing. Gears Ultimate is great and still reviewing better than most new games. Its aged just fine.

84 when I last checked Gamerankings by the way.