Aeolus451 said:
Nem said:
If that is the case, then one of those reviewers is a bad reviewer. How much something is rewarding is part of the design of the game. If reviews are this volatile and opinated then the scoring system makes no sense and is arbitrary.
At the end of the day, what we have in this case is the same game with less features (and this was a game created with the gamepad in mind and loses alot of its appeal without it). How can it possibly score higher? I can't account this to simply "opinion" and i can't clear the publication of the past review published for the same game. None of this is serious. If it isnt serious, i can't trust either of their reviews. Both of them are untrustworthy.
Imagine Fallout 4. It comes out for PS4 and X1 and performs the same on both systems but you give it to different people to review. At the end of the day they have different opinions and one gives it an 9 and the other a 6. Its their opinions but now the PS4 version is a 6 and the X1 is a 9. Does this make any sense? Would you be ok with that and why are you ok with it in this case?
|
Yes, it would make sense. To be fair, Bethesda's games usually run worse on playstation consoles so I actually expect the review to be worse for the PS4 port. That could be different with Fallout 4, though. We'll see on that.
It's asinine to think that that different reviewers would give the same score to different ports to a game. Also the wii u's version was pretty glitchy and the controller is a "love or hate it" type of situation with gamers. If the other consoles' version of this game isn't glitchy then it should automatically get a better score than the wii u version in my opinion.
Reviewers are individuals who will always come to different conclusions and judgements more often than agreeing on something.
|
That wasnt the comparison it was if both performed equally.
If you think that its ok to give vastly different scores to the same game, then by all means. All i ask is consistency. Lets have it on every game and not only on the ones that are easiest to pick on.
