By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
mornelithe on 19 July 2015
Edit Thread
JinxRake said:
BMaker11 said:

They're not using Superman Prime, though. In fact, they're actually not even consistent with the Superman they are using. They used a composite Superman, despite saying they're restricting him to New 52. That whole "lifting infinity" thing......non-canon. There's no consistency in the continuity of the Superman character, so, ultimately, both death battles don't even make sense. Superman is, essentially, a different person in each incarnation. Screw Attacks ignores that and just puts the best characteristics of each Superman and mashes that into one character. Whereas Goku is just one continuity. Any one Superman (other than Superman Prime), Goku should be able to beat, whether it be an easy battle or a tough one. But when you take the best feats of 5 different versions of Superman, then put that all into one, then the guy is unbeatable, even compared to the actual gods of any given universe. 

I wouldn't be surprised if the ScrewAttack version of Superman could one-shot The One Above All

Pretty sure Red Son Superman could destroy Goku quite finely, considering his personality.

All Star Superman is basically a no brainer for smudging Goku five ways from Sunday. 

 

What a character should or should not be able to do is NOT up for the debate of the fans. The discussion is fine and dandy and it's all in good fun that we annoy one another with these types of things...but it always comes down to preferences. 

 

Also, to whoever says Goku was supposed to be limitless: learn your DB and your DB background story. Goku was never meant to be reach beyond Frieza. Heck, he was never supposed to be some planet cracking super god. But fans demanded it, Toriyama was all too happy for the money, and here we are, with Cyan Hair Goku. 

"What a character should or should not be able to do is NOT up for the debate of the fans."

Irony is so ironic.

Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster (original creators of Superman) died in 1992 and 1996 respectively, by your way of thinking, all Superman canon after their deaths is not permissible.  Goku wins.