| ChronotriggerJM said: LOL god I hope your kidding xD You act as if I HATE the Wii, I don't hate either :P I don't even hate Nintendo for that matter xD Just look at that final screen shot you posted of bowser's castle, tell me that Bowser doesn't look more vibrant in the gamecube version. When I think Nintendo, I think color and imagination, not HDR lighting and blur effects. You wanted honest opinions right? I HONESTLY think the Gamecube version looks better, and by better I mean better use of color. The character models are too simple to really show superiority on that front, just look at the trucks in both on the highway, they're both rectangle with flat textures x.x what more do you want from me? So basing it on that, I'll go with the one that has better color, and sadly, thats the gamecube version x.x |
Fair enough. My opinion is that the GC version has solid, primary colors, while the Wii version has slightly more subdued, but better looking and better lit colors. The comparison from the N64 to the GC was the same, N64 had brighter (primary) colors, but little or no variety, muddier textures, and poorer lighting. I personally think the Wii version looks better (albeit slightly) than the GC. You are entitled to your opinion.
I have just noticed a trend of non-nintendo fans consistently saying the GC version of ______ game looks better than the Wii version without stating any reasons why.
Edit: as to your above post about not having played the game. That was my point as well as the first question I asked in my original post. It seems to me that a lot of non-ninty fans are very quick to say that Wii games look worse than their GC counterparts without ever having played them. Having played SSBB, MKWii, SMG, and MP3, on a 120" projection screen, I can say from experience that there are significant improvements in all of the above, most notably SMG and MP3.
