The OP is right. Just because there is a game you don't personally like, it doesn't mean you should call it "garbage". There's such a thing as "not my cup of tea". Wish more people would realize that.
There are plenty of things I hated about Persona 4 Golden, but I decided to stick with the game and ended up having an incredible experience. But even if I ended up hating parts of it or not enjoying the game overall, I'd still be aware that that doesn't automatically make the game garbage. It just makes it something that doesn't match my tastes.
And yes, fanboys are called fanoboys for a reason. They don't apply logic and have blind faith in their company of choice, and try to convince themselves that the competition is trash, when it's far from it. Even if you don't like Ninty/cartoony games or old IP's, you can still see that the quality is there.
I found the battle system in Nino Kuni perfect. Others hated it. I hate the battle system in the Witcher. I still get that even though it's not just me, there are plenty of people who actually enjoy it; it's not trash, just not the kind of game I want to play.
But you can find sad, close minded people everywhere. Pop music, movies, politics, sports, etc.
