Which will sell more lifetime globally? Halo MCC XBox1 vs Uncharted Collection PS4

[cpg716]

Burek said:

cpg716 said:

Huh? First 3 HALO games sold 27 million..    so if we compared.. first 3 games.. HALO is 6 million ahead..  Add Halo:Reach and Halo:4 and we are at 47 million HALO sold..        how does 21 million for 3 games give Uncharted a win?   Oh.. and add Halo:MCC and the HALO series has sold almost 50 million..

So, using your math, Uncharted collection should struggle to reach 1 million.

Hope you do know that game sales don't rely strictly on arithmetic.

How else do you explain, for instance, TLOU remaster, which singlehandedly outsold MCC, even though the original sold 7 times less than Halo games?

Um.. No.. The person said because Uncharted series sold 21 million that the Remaster would outsell Halo:MCC..   I was pointing out how that logic didnt make sense.. as Halo outsold Uncharted in every single way..       

BUT..     TLoU wasn't really a remaster..    It was released within a year on a new generation console.. This wasn't a series of games that have been out for SEVERAL years and play by millions already OVER and OVER..     Very different product then Halo:MCC and Uncharted Series..    Same as GTA5..  I don't consider it the same..      These were just new releases on NEW consoles for the most part..       not several year old games.. put together and pushed out.

So.. I dont think you can compare them..      HALO utlimately had/has more of a FAN base then Uncharted..   Doesn't sound like there will be big upgrades to the Uncharted games.. so really the purchasers will mainly be people who DIDN't play the games..  Also.. with the new one coming out withing 4-6 months of this release.. WAY less time for people who want their Uncharted fix..