SanAndreasX on 26 May 2015
For me, I'm going to have to say Fallout 3 and New Vegas. They had great post-apocalyptic atmosphere and set pieces. The combat definitely left much to be desired. I didn't mind the shooting so much, because I used VATS anyway. If I wanted to play a shooter, I'd play Halo or Call of Duty. But melee combat felt like a slap fight between paper dolls. Plus, you really couldn't interact with the environment much, for all the geography in the game. New Vegas was definitely a big improvement in the gameplay department over Fallout 3.
And in the end, I loved both of these games. Other than Valkyria Chronicles and Ni no Kuni, Fallout: NV and Fallout 3 are my favorite games of the PS3/Wii/360 generation (in that order.
