IllegalPaladin on 27 April 2008
I don't think horror is completely dependent on how much supplies you have. In Resident Evil 4, I felt that instead of doing anything scary (except for a few areas of course), the entire game had just turned into an action title instead of something that actually tried to scare me. The only parts where my blood would get flowing is when an enemy is rushing me and I'm trying to stop them before I get hit, which is similar to pretty much every other game.
I guess I've gotten over the nightmares of the dogs busting through the window in the first Resident Evil if the forth game was supposed to be scary.
