By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
tbone51 said:

Because im talking about majority of GoTY. I didnt list GoTY for Polygon/Ign/etc only. Metacritic reflects that, so i ask again really?

Also you cant cherry pick a console for multiplats, its always the one with the most reviews for obvious reasons. Games you listed are mostly games that won GoTY from 1-3 gaming sites/reviewers/etc.

Once again METACRITIC DOES REFLECT MAJORITY OF GOTY. 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Game_of_the_Year_awards

Do everyone a favor and actually research it.
There have beem many games on many platforms that scored well but didn't even get nominated in many cases for a GOTY let alone win one.

Implying that splatoon may theoretically (since it is entirely a guess at this point) get 90+ and thus instantly becomes a contender for GOTY is disingenuous. 

That isn't to say it cannot win a GOTY award, but that whether or not it wins one will not be based on it's metacritic score.