Highest Rated Exclusives (MC): 8th Gen Updated

[outlawauron]

BraLoD said:

Zekkyou said:

BraLoD said:
I don't think games like TLOU or Xenoblade should be removed from their original gen.
They were exclusive games to their gens, late ports don't take it away.

Also cross-gens titles should be picked as well, but only to one gen, the trick would be choose it, probably the best to always go with the better version, even as I would disagree at some cases xD

If they remain exclusive to one brand as Nintendo, Sony and MS, it should be alright.

I agree, which is why i think the 2 list plan is the best solution. It maintains the original's value while also providing a literal present day comparison for those that want it. People can't complain about more data!

As for cross-gen (ala brand exclusive) titles, while i haven't fully decided how to treat them yet, if i go with the 2 list plan the 7th gen version will be added to one of the 7th gen 'true' lists, while the 8th gen version will be limited to the console exclusive list.

The biggest question mark right now is how i treat titles like SSB on the 3DS and WiiU, or Tearaway on the Vita and PS4. The two versions are built on the same foundation and share a lot of content, but with the home console version being an expanded and refined experience (which it could be argued justifies regarding it as a separate game). 

Exclusivity sure is complicated these days

Indeed

Also, Tearaway Unfolded should fall in the same category as TLOU:R.

SSB Wii U should be taken as Little Big Planet 3 I uess, it's a cross title between two different platforms from the same brand, even as it came a little later.

Unfolded is not a remaster. They re-developed the game and even said half the game is completely different from what it was on Vita. That hardly qualifies as a remaster.