Why I think SMT x FE will be a lighter version of Persona 5

[b00moscone]

spemanig said:

b00moscone said:

How so? I don't see the Persona IP being bad, and remember what I said, a lighter game is not equal to a bad game.

But it does equal a game that does not reflect what they advertized, which was a cross over between main series SMT game crossed over with Fire Emblem. Don't be annoyed when people are upset that Atlus said one thing, did something else, and then got criticized for it. The revealed game could have been a Zelda clone. "Why should people be pissed? Zelda's a great game. The devs even said that they didn't reveal much FE bits yet." If the initial teaser from two years ago had even one Persona character in it, and the teaser image showed tokyo in the bright daylight, and the music that accompanied it was some bubbly jpop song instead of the ominous, clearly SMT-esc, tune, no one would be upset right now.

But the thing with your example is that Zelda and FE are two different genres, SMT, FE and Persona are all RPGs, so a connection can be made between the three games. Plus, I think its way to early to say that they didn't deliver on their promise. Even now you can pick up stuff from SMT and FE, for example, the fact that the devs said themselves that there will be a fantasy world where the Fire Emblem characters will be, and the enemies represent SMT enemies, so I don't see hwo they're nto on their way on delivering their promise.

i've already said this, but Atlus isn't dumb enough to make a game called SMT x FE, and have it not be anything do to with them, because it wouldn't be SMT x FE then.