A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[Iyasu]

super_etecoon said:
I'd like to see a 3d secret of mana. I think that would fit in the Nintendo universe very well. Just borrow the time, the co-op, the cutesy feel, the weapon system and you've got gold. I'm not sure how well it would sell, but it'd be a ton of fun to play. As an added bonus, allow the game to switch between 2d and 3d at will to really give it a kick in the nostalgia pants.

Pretty much this. I'd love an Action RPG like Secret of Mana in a similar graphical style like A Link between Worlds.
And if they'd make a SoM style game then I hope without something like those ring menues, they slowed down the pace in combat quite a lot.

I doubt it would sell millions, so it's probably a void that a small Nintendo studio would have to fill.