A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[fatslob-:O]

Wyrdness said:

Then you should open your eyes because Paper Mario is easily seen as a great RPG by many with the original and TTYD seen as two of the best RPGs to ever surface. Awakening is easily a great RPG as well considered that by both many who have played it and critics and Mario and Luigi is an RPG series that is the counterpart to Paper Mario in that it builds on what Super Mario RPG brought but goes down a different route then the former. I don't know where you're getting all this tbh as the are many things that contradict what you've posted.

I'm sure Paper Mario is decent and the rest of the games you mentioned but maybe my criteria for "great" is different from everyone else on here ...