A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[sc94597]

fatslob-:O said:

sc94597 said:

Pokemon is not flying off the shelfs? Earthbound/Mother doesn't have a cult following? Paper Mario games didn't sell between 1-3 million? Mario & Luigi for the 3DS didn't sell almost 2 million? If sales mean anything in regards to quality, then all of these games are better RPGs than something like Persona or Tales of. 

Pokemon is not developed by Nintendo ...

Paper Mario is a decent series but not exactly great. 

These games are probably indeed better than Persona or Tales of ...

What does "developed by Nintendo" even mean? There are many developers in Nintendo. Usually when we say a game is a Nintendo game, we mean published by Nintendo, and that is what the OP meant.