A Nintendo action RPG, good idea or bad?

[sc94597]

fatslob-:O said:

sc94597 said:

That could be said for any game. I guess you are saying it's your personal opinion, but the tone of your post made it seem like you believed it was a consensus opinion. 

They aren't exactly flying off the shelfs ...

Pokemon is not flying off the shelfs? Earthbound/Mother doesn't have a cult following? Paper Mario games didn't sell between 1-3 million? Mario & Luigi for the 3DS didn't sell almost 2 million? If sales mean anything in regards to quality, then all of these games are better RPGs than something like Persona or Tales of.