GTA 4 vs Yakuza 4 - which game is better?

[Xenoverse3]

KazumaKiryu said:

Xenoverse3 said:
Yakuza 3 was better than both. Yakuza 4 was good too but the setting had become really stale being that its the same setting from the three previous games.

Yakuza 3 had an Okinawa based setting too but Yakuza 4 got rid of that only to replace it with empty rooftops...

you think so really ? ^^ its funny, because... i personally think, yakuza 1/2/4 >>> 3.

And yakuza 5 is the biggest game, i hear. why do you like yakuza 3 soo ? = ) its interesting for me.

the people here vote for yakuza 4 and not for gta iv, i'm sup.

I just really liked the Okinawa part of the game. I also liked how it started at a slower pace with missions focused on the kids at the orphanage which made it different from most other games I'd ever played.

 

And after playing that Yakuza 4 was very much the same game. I was disappointed they took Okinawa out of the game and didn't offer a replacement setting.

 

They replaced the sunshine filled Okinawa for just some empty rooftops that there was no need to go up. It was a step backwards.

 

Yakuza 5 looks like big step up though.