GTA 4 vs Yakuza 4 - which game is better?

[Xenoverse3]

Yakuza 3 was better than both. Yakuza 4 was good too but the setting had become really stale being that its the same setting from the three previous games.

Yakuza 3 had an Okinawa based setting too but Yakuza 4 got rid of that only to replace it with empty rooftops...