Wow, this thread is pretty fascinating to read. I do love a good meaty discussion.
In the end, I picked "I don't know" since I really don't. I was leaning heavily towards "Yes, but only if post-op" but I think I would have to still judge the situation at hand. In my experience, most transgender individuals, even post-op, don't quite fit my taste, looks-wise.
I consider myself pretty well-versed in LGBT rights and issues and transgender issues still are a major puzzle to me. Probably should educate myself better on the topic before I speak too loudly on it. :P
It'll be awhile before I figure out how to do one of these. :P