Alright let's go.
5 - Axum (Great taste in profile pictures, in games, and in mods. Actually maybe that last one should give him 1 point...but his posts are always fun to read and he's a great guy to talk to, so he can keep 5).
4 - Slarvax (I can't begin to describe how grateful I am for all his work in my thread and around the site; without him I would be nothing).
3 - Outlaw (He's a mainstay now, and although timezones and other commitments keep up apart, nothing will be better than a good chat with him).
2 - Vivster (10,000 posts in and still going strong. He's an awesome guy who definitely has his moments, here's to another 10,000!).
1 - Anfebious (I wish I could put you higher, because the few times I've chatted to you off site have been awesome. In other rounds you almost certainly would have, but I haven't seen you as active lately and that's a shame).
As I said, other rounds all 5 of these could have got top points. How cruel you are, random.org!