By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Honestly, I think everything is fair game. To call something overrated is simply to challenge the prevailing positive opinion about that thing. If someone thinks a popular game plays poorly, he or he can call it overrated. Similarly, if someone thinks an entire genre is overestimated or that the game in question left a negative legacy, then he or she can call it overrated too.

There's no science to this. It's a personal opinion of another set of personal opinions, after all.