Could Rockstar make a better Zelda than Nintendo?

[tolu619]

padib said:

No

Sony japan could though. The gameplay would suffer but the art direction would be perfect.

Even then gameplay is very important in Zelda, though Nintendo was able to mess up Skyward Sword, so.

Wait, what? Are you one of those who hates the motion controls, or you actually think the gameplay is worse than previous Zelda games? In other words, ifthe game had classic controls, would you like it better? I've beaten 6 Zelda games (played 10) and not only do I think Skyward Sword has the best set of dungeons so far, I also think it has less filler than most other Zeldas (the train sections in Spirit Tracks, sailing in Windwaker, the large, empty hyrule field in Twilight Princess, etc)