jetforcejiminy said:
twin snakes sold like shit (less than 500k). pikmin 2 was a huge decline from pikmin (+400k less, or more than 35% of pikmin's sales). jungle beat, while a terrific game, was viewed initially as a novelty and sold accordingly, selling only 25% of what the last major dk game did (dk 64). this is in no way comparable to a new zelda game (which routinely sell 4m+, even on the gc), or a new star fox (which sold almost 2m even when it sucked in star fox adventures, with star fox 64 selling 4m+). paper mario (2.25m) and metroid prime 2 (1.33m), which you missed, were the must-own titles that year. neither sold well compared to the previous installments. 2004 was a bad year for the gc globally, let's not pretend otherwise. the wii u's 2004 was actually 2013, when there were no games rather than the embarrassment of riches the gamecube had at launch. smash, sunshine, metriod prime, wind waker in the same 12-16 month period! and then mario kart at the end of 2003! |
This thread and our conversation is specifically about Japan so please leave out global sales/releases. Metroid Prime 2 didn't release in Japan until 2005 so that game is out.
It doesn't matter that Twin Snakes sold like shit, it was still a major release for GC in 2004 just as Wonderful 101/Bayonetta 2/Devil's Third are considered major releases for Wii U despite selling like shit or likely to sell like shit.
Pikmin 2 sold virtually the same as the original in Japan (560k) so no decline there.
Also while yes Zelda is a huge worldwide release, it has not been a very huge series in Japan for quite some time now. It use to sell over 1 million back in the 80's/90's but Twilight Princess/Skyward Sword only sold 600k/370k.
Star Fox has declined with each and every installment in Japan and with the series being dormant for nearly a decade, it's hard to see the game selling very strongly.
Basically hear the comparison for GC 2004 vs Wii U 2015 in Japan
Paper Mario/Mario Tennis=Mario Maker (Mario spinoffs)
Mario Party 6=Mario Party 10 (same series)
DK Jungle Beat/Konga 2=Kirby/Yoshi (novel concepts with DK games selling similar to Yoshi New Island/Canvas Curse)
Twin Snakes= Devil's Third (major 3rd party collaboration that will likely sell poorly)
Pikmin 2=Star Fox (hardcore yet relatively niche genres)
Naruto Clash of Ninja 3/Xenoblade Chronicles X (hardcore Japanese oriented games, Naruto on GC actually sold much better than Xenoblade on Wii)
That leaves Splatoon & Zelda which I already explained Zelda is no longer a huge franchise in Japan and Splatoon is an unproven, new ip although it does have potential.
While I agree with u that Wii U 2015 lineup is better than GC 2004 lineup in Japan, we are talking about sales here and GC sold 600k in Japan in 2004, Wii U will likely sell about 750-800k in Japan this year, which is down from last year with Donkey Kong/Mario Kart/Smash Bros releasing and are some of Nintendo's biggest series. That means Wii U will likely be down next year so about 600k seems pretty likely.
When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.







