I am rarely dissapointed in the games I buy, since I don't buy many but then ones I do, I know i will enjoy endlessly. I also don't want to bash games from other companies I have not played. If I had to pick a game I played and felt pretty bleh:
Bioshock Infinite. I finished the last of Us right before going into this game and it just paled in comparison, as far as adventure, story driven games go. It was far too convoluted for it's own good and everything between cutscenes was just fight, after fight, after fight (The first 20~30% of the game had pretty good pacing though, between fighting and "exploring") Much like TLoU (in a difficulty other than grounded), you are not penalized for getting wrecked multiple times (losing money made no sense) Being in FPS made it hard to relate to Booker and He was a little emotionless for most of the game for my taste.
"Trick shot? The trick is NOT to get shot." - Lucian
