IGN Finally Gives Smash Bros Wii U a 9.8!

[Super_Boom]

sundin13 said:

Why would I complain about the things they get right? I personally have no real qualms with the Pokemon score, but I don't see any logic in discounting everything someone does just because you disagree with a specific thing (or a few specific things)...it isn't a black and white issue (its an ORAS issue...sorry, bad pun). I will complain about the specific instances in which a site produces something that I find to be bullshit, but why would I complain about the things they produce that aren't bullshit? This review is well written and fairly comprehensive, with a score that matches the critiques and the critiques and praise being logical and well elucidated... why should I complain?

I genuinely do not understand what your problem is here...

Very well stated. That's pretty much the same issue I had, only explained much more clearly. There's nothing hypocritical about finding fault with what you believe to be a flawed review, and no fault with a great review. It makes zero sense for me to feel obligated to complain about a review just because I didn't like a completely different review posted on the same site.

Speaking in general of course. Like I said, I have no idea if either game warrants their specific score.