| prinz_valium said: okay now i know. i would rate most of them similar. just wilson 1 Point better for his agility but i still dont get, why peyton ist just a 3/10. i would give him at least a 4 or even 5. his footwork in the pocket is really well and he got decent arms. and to throw accurate, requires some athletic ablility, too 25% or 1/3. the rest would be Talent, Training and concentration ill give him 4.5/10 |
You're probably right in context really.
I think I overly docked him for :
Zero rushing threat (though his walk-in TD was hilarious last year)
Not much of a dodger at all honestly, he beats you with quick outs and brains really instead of extending plays on his feet
A tendency to throw some ducks up there. Almost all on-target, but sometimes slow and floaty, or wobbly balls.
None I this is stuff I say to pick on him or call him below average as a package. As a QB, he's top of the pack because he's a freaking commander out there. He is fast as hell at reads, adjustments, and when his arm is firing right, those balls find their perfect little spot in the universe. But I have to be realistic about the entire set of variables. Like I said, imagine Peyton's brain in Kap's body. That would be truly terrifying. Instead of only being able to murder you with precise, brilliant passing, he could torch the pants off you if you left him a lane.
