By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
comflash2 said:
LurkerJ said:

An Interestin bit about animals. The guy in the video linked above by your fellow Muslim says that anything non human (even stars?) is considered a muslim. They are in heaven by default as a result. It does make some sense from your religion's perspective at least. However, the merciness part still doesn't sit with me at all. For Allah to call himself the most merciful he has to really go out of his way to show mercy at all times. Which I don't believe he does. 

If you want to believe that the test we are given is fair, just and merciful, go ahead. I, however, believe that Allah doesn't deserve the most merciful award. As I said earlier, it would've been more merciful if we weren't created at all. 

I would like to hear your input on the discussion I am having with your fellow Muslim here http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6760652 . I will understand if don't have the time to do it or you simply don't care enough to continue. Thank you either way.


You understand that LurkerJ. I think, you quite interested to understand Islam instead of just blindly bashing islam... so i'll entertain your question.

All of the creation is servant of Allah (zakir naik use the word Muslim), however, they wont get benefit to the heaven. Only freewill creation will be rewarded to be in heaven (thats why Human accept the challenge), and risking to be into hell. There is 2 kind of freewill creation that will go to Heaven and Hell... they are Human and Jinn. Human made from sand (which adam made from) and Jinn made from fire (Iblis (not sure what it is in english), syaitan (devil) etc is Jinn) and they both will be judge either to go into the Heaven and Hell. Other creation will not go to either of this.

Edit: I misunderstood. I will come to this later. EDIT2: Thanks. I want to read more about The Jinn. Intriguing. Animals don't go to heaven? Your friends said they would. Which is it?