I really enjoyed Beyond Two Souls. Kept me away from my PS4 until I finished it. Not perfect but doesn't deserve a lot of the flack it gets.
The only other game on that list I played was Eternal Darkness. It looked cheap back when it came out (graphically) but it sucked me in like few other games have. Don't know how well it holds up and I can't find my copy but back then, I was starved for a new game and ED really blew me away with its mind fucks.
Are the other games underrated? I thought most, if not all, did very well critically and amongst players.
*edit* Oh, I played Shenmue, too. I thought it was short but spectacular as a showcase for what the Dreamcast could do. Now, I don't think it's that good. If anything, it's probably kinda overrated.
