| Wonktonodi said: @ cone I have expressed thoughts on them all before. But I'll try and say a little more now. Radish does have some of his more common traits that he's done as town. But some of then felt forced. Like he was just going through the motions. He's not really helped with scum hunting was rather absent from the end of day one and didn't really have much to add when he had days to really get caught up. He's likely sum in my opinion. Prof. I miss some of his in your face investigating though between his vacation and trying to tone it down this is what we get. Leaning scum from the lack of hunting, some odd reasoning and my little meta list. Padib. Some of his logic baffles me as I have pointed out. His role hints are interesting and troubling. His certainty that both kills are the same faction makes we wonder where his certainty ends and assumptions begin. Why no possibility for a vig? |
Yeah, I knew you'd already posted some thoughts but thought a nice consice post to catch up as you'd asked everyone else for one was a good idea.
The most concerning thing for me about Padib is that he just posted this role hint pretty much unprovoked. Was he under any sort of real pressure? Not from what I could see. There must be some reason for doing it, but honestly I can't see one. And surely if you're invincible tonight as he claims, and town, you'd want to keep that a secret. Unless he was forced into doing it by his Mafia allies.
Consider this possibility, for example. Sparks and padib are on the same Mafia team. Sparks is under fire, and thus is looking for a way to draw attention off of him. What better way to do that than role claim, perhaps overexaggurate in the process, to try and steer conversation away from Sparks? People are going to wait until the third day at least for padib to see if his role is accurate or not, they'd think, so why not give it a try?
Just a thought, and it's probably wrong, but you never know right?
Essay Pro