So it looks like GOTY will be going to either DA:I, Bayonetta 2 or LBP3

[Mystro-Sama]

GTAexpert said:

KLAMarine said:

GTAexpert said:

GOW >> Bayonetta, both storywise and gameplaywise.

GOW has a great narrative, variety in combat, epic sense of scale, intense atmosphere, great enemy designs and amazing boss fights. Bayonetta doesn't even come close. Heck, even Platinum's own Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance is better than Bayonetta.

Two words: Frame rate.

GOW3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kYnydQ4t0aU

MGR:R had a similar problem: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u3xynugwVCU

This is a sin in a fast-paced hack-and-slash man. As for enemy designs, Bayo had them too. Those angels looked trippy as hell. I'd say they looked more intricate than GoW enemy design which was good, don't get me wrong.

Framerate doesn't make a game, and it only breaks one when the framerate is absolutely horrible, like 20fps. This is not decisive enough to make one game better than the other. Besides, GOW isn't very fast-paced in general so it matters even less in that case.

Bayonetta's enemies are not poorly designed by any means, I just meant that GOW's enemies are better. And they are certainly better than MGR: R ones, but that game wins out on various other factors.

Are you kidding me? The genres framerate is most essential in are hack n slash and racers. There is no disputing that.

 

And the staple of a good hack n slash is speed and fluidity. At least you're aware GoW doesn't really deliver in this department.