Zelda Windwaker HD is number one and totally slaughters MK8 and M3DW.
Out of the exclusives I'd say Donkey Kong, Tropical Freeze would get second place. It's a great game and I keep going back it.
If you count multiplats Deus Ex: Human revolution would probably be the second best Wii U game, although I've never played it on Wii U. I might get the wii U version if I ever want to replay it.