July 2014 NPD Thread! PS4: 187k, XBO: 131k, Wii U: 81k

[Ninsect]

HylianSwordsman said:

Ninsect said:

Yeah but you were talking about specific titles.

The OP of this thread contains specific titles. VGChartz has their LTD sales totals for each title broken up into lists by platform, and each list is ordered by WW sales, with NA sales, Europe sales, Japan sales, and ROW sales listed next to it.

http://www.vgchartz.com/platform/42/nintendo-3ds/

There's the list of 3DS titles by WW sales, according to VG Chartz. It doesn't have US sales, just NA sales. Compare the NPD estimated LTD US sales of the 3DS titles in the OP, to the respective VGChartz estimated North American sales in the list I linked above. VGChartz has NA sales for Pokemon as lower than NPD has US sales for Pokemon. So definitely undertracked. The other titles I mentioned are really close, but since NPD has just US sales while VGChartz is claiming to represent NA, the VGChartz numbers should be a decent amount higher, but they're not. Go ahead and do the comparisions yourself if you like. If you really think NA sales outside of the US are that low, I respect your opinion, but also respectfully disagree, it just seems very unlikely to me. So I think those titles are probably undertracked on VGC.

Yes, but you do know you can check VGC US sales, right? Just click on the game and hit the USA tab.