July 2014 NPD Thread! PS4: 187k, XBO: 131k, Wii U: 81k

[DonFerrari]

steverhcp02 said:

DonFerrari said:

steverhcp02 said:

Ummm im not gonna drop my trousers and start measuring with you guys about "downplaying" It doesnt matter if its a remaster at all. Youre taking a snapshot of a game that sold a lot in a slow period and extrapolating it. Its just a fact if you take a month with one console haveing a big release its going to skew the numbers.

No piss contest... it's just a game that already released, sold for 5 days and were against one of the best sellers from Nintendo and WD. And if the month is so slow let's see how much HW it was sold.

I don't understand your logic. I am not downplaying anything. All I am saying is youre taking a month where there is one clear cut exclusive game thats old a ton and extrapolating it against other consoles. It's just not a fair comparison to make on a larger scale.

I'm thoroughly impressed with TLOU:R sales but  tooting the horn about comparing gross sales across consoles in light of a single titles dwarfing software does not provide a fair comparison.

I didn't said you were downplaying. Just that to consider a sole game tipping the balance so much that all other softwares on both concorrents and the own platform are dwarves isn't accurate.