Contradiction: Isn't TLOU:R also giving gamers choice like people argue for EA Access?

[starcraft]

SWORDF1SH said:

starcraft said:

Well then as others have pointed out, on VGC there is no equating them. EA Access has copped far more flak on these forums than TLOU:R. Maybe try a different forum, where perhaps the balance is different?

I don't know.

Really?!? I see a lot of people defending EA Access by saying it gives gamers choice but also a lot of people slating TLOU:R (of course there are people doing the opposite, ratios, I don't know). I'm just bringing in a different POV on things.  Also like stated in the OP, it's more about remasters in general while using TLOU:R as the main example because it the most recent and one that seems to taken more flak than ones before it.

If you are for remasters then why are you arguing. If not, please explain why. Also if you are one of these people that says EA access give you choice, why doesn't this apply for Remastered games. We really do not need somebody to point out "bu bu bu but wees get more flak blah blah blah". Contribute to the debate, give us your opinion. Having a debate is fine, having your own opinion is fine, locking horns over opinions is fine.

Fair enough.

In a sense, both offer gamers choice. If that is the beginning and end of the question this thread raises, then the answer is self-evident.