Contradiction: Isn't TLOU:R also giving gamers choice like people argue for EA Access?

[MoHasanie]

We've had so many threads about this topic..
There is nothing wrong with TLOUR. Some remasters are obvious cash grabs like GTA V, but TLOUR is not since many have not played the game. If people didn't want it, then it wouldn't be selling well. 

The PS Nation had a thread title a few weeks ago that said that TLOUR was the most hated remaster, and even though it sounded dumb, I'm starting to think that its true.