Reasonable on 31 March 2008
Given the existence of game rankings, metacritic, etc. I think unless Ioi can come up with a way of keeping game scores in line (i.e. preventing stupid voting) I'd rather see the scores dropped and just have game pages focused on sales data and feedback and links to metacritic/game rankings instead.
Given I doubt he can stop silly voting I'd say just drop the scores (which is what people are doing anyway, right?)
Personally I'd bring back 'games I own' but allow each member to score their own games - so if you look at my profile you see what I rate COD4, etc.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
