By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Pk9394 on 12 June 2007
Edit Thread
Dallinor said:
Pk9394 said:
I think you can get the lowest HD DVD player for $250 range now, just check some hot deal site.

anyway like bulletstopper say, there is really no difference between HD format and regular DVD on a standard tube screen TV. to really tell the difference you'll need a 50" screen or bigger. I tested this out with my cousin's ps3 with my 50" plasma (only support upto 1080i) and with my cousin's 56" DLP screen(support 1080p). when hooked on STD T.V we cant hardly tell the difference, then hooked on to those two big TV we start see a some difference in picture quality but that increase in little quality doesnt justify the price jump of purchasing a 50" TV and a HD or Blue ray Player.

oh we test it on a 37" LCD TV too, as it come out. we can hardly tell the difference.

This format war is so much different from DVD, people dont have to buy a new TV to experience these new format, but now they need to buy a big TV to experience these new format. and space is another constraint consumer having. 50" plasma or LCD isnt small!!!!!

The HD DVD players for $250 don't give a great picture quality. You need to buy a $400 one for it to deliver the goods.

This is just a woeful effort to twist numbers. So they sold 60% of the stand alone players with a year's headstart against blu ray. Yet had we checked that figure a month ago, they probably had 65% of the standalone player market.

So then, after excluding the PS3 numbers from the first statistic, they then seem to go full loop, and include the PS3 numbers for their second statistic, in an effort to make the attach rate look better.

 


I wasnt doing the comparison with a HD DVD player, was doing comparison using the ps3 running a blue ray movie on different TVs and running the same movie on a DVD on those same TVs.

I havent tried HD DVD comparison because I dont own any HD DVD players.

one thing though, the avg joe dont care much about which players have better quality, the only thing they'll notice is the $200 price mark compare to the $499 price mark, of course for tech geeks, we know the $200 model got avg quality compare to$300 model HD DVD players.