By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
o_O.Q said:
Dr.Henry_Killinger said:
o_O.Q said:

Uh... So therefore you acknowledge that I didn't say that... Ok that's good what I posted was quite clear whatever further inferences you make are all on you

As for evidence that's what Google is for

Ironically, http://lmgtfy.com/?q=burden+of+proof

And finally the point about free will leads back to what I just said about values influencing behavior 

Sure you may have free will but if you're following values with the understanding that should you choose to reject them you will be punished and that those values are the only way to live your life

If you do not have enough mental fortitude to decide your own values, then the one who taught you those values are responsible, Religion isn't institincual

You're going to be coerced into making certain decisions based on those values that should be obvious... So ultimately what I'm saying is that as a theist no you do not have free will under certain conditions 

Said values do not have a will that acts upon anything, especially since Religion is subjective, open to interpretation, yes you can fault someone for their interpretations and being cooerced. Not to mention you always have free will as long as you understand the situation you are in.

For example, Religion A says something like "an adulter will be punished by death" and you interpret it as you should kill your wife for cheating or go to hell etc. The prospect of hell incentivizes the action of killing your wife, but you still have to accept it and valuate what is more important to you.

You're blaming the gun, not the shooter.

EDIT: Not to mention, another person whose reads the same line and interprets that a cheating wife will be punished by god or whatever and they do nothing.

Not only are you blaming the gun, but you're the one that loaded it with bullets in the first place.


At this point I'm not even really sure what we're talking about now but it seems to me though that you're insulting theists 

"If you do not have enough mental fortitude to decide your own values"

That is the point of theism that a set of values is used by a set of people and sure there will be some differences in interpretation bur from what I've experienced for the most part the values are universal across a group

*eye twitches*

*reaches for die*



starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS