Should full CGI trailers be banned?

[Torillian]

TheLastStarFighter said:

Torillian said:

While I'm sitting here surprised that anyone could not be excited after that video.  Different strokes for different foks I guess.  

True, and I respect that.  It just wasn't a game. I only get excited by games.  At least titles like Uncharted and Zelda were in-game scripted scenes and from existiting IP's where we know what the gameplay will be like.  I suppose you could stretch Darksouls over what was seen from the Bloodborne CGI and imagine something great.

If there were no background for the video then sure I could see the comment, but it's made by From Software and the creator of Demon's Souls himself, in collaboration with SCEJ, and we already had a ton of leaked gameplay to show that it isn't a stretch to think it'll have that Dark Souls gameplay and vibe.  Everything seen after the trailer confirmed that as well.