| Aielyn said: The point with CoD3 was that they made an effort with the game itself. It couldn't have had online, because the online infrastructure wasn't set up at the time. Meanwhile, the game itself proved that people were interested in FPS with Wiimote controls. So did Red Steel. Also, CoD 3's quality issue is part of why sales of the franchise declined rather than holding steady (combined with failure to release CoD4 in a timely manner, which meant that the fanbase for the franchise all moved to the other systems). The whole point of that argument is that it proves that games of those sorts can sell well (either absolutely or relatively) on Nintendo systems. Other examples of the point include Resident Evil 4, House of the Dead, Star Wars: The Force Unleashed, and Silent Hill: Shattered Memories. It demonstrates that the claim that games like GTA couldn't sell well on Nintendo systems is just plain false, and you haven't provided a single argument against what I've said. What you've done is argued for why the games sold as well as they did... but the key point is, they sold. They sold better or as well as they did on other systems, when the quality was there and the effort was put in. When they released low-quality ports that were ignored when it comes to advertising, the games unsurprisingly flopped. Let me put it another way - you don't justify a claim that unicorns don't exist by looking only in your backyard, seeing no unicorns, and going "I have found evidence of no unicorns, therefore they don't exist". You need to be exhaustive - the claim needs to be general, to apply across the board. You have to check everywhere that you possibly can for unicorns before declaring that they don't exist. If you find unicorns in some other part of the world, you don't ignore them and declare that unicorns don't exist just because they don't fit the desire you had for them to exist in your backyard. In exactly the same way, the fact that you can point to a heap of flops doesn't prove that GTA would flop, but the fact that I can point to some games that didn't proves that GTA could be successful (not that it would, but that it could). |
Okay, I admit it. GTA could be successful on Wii U.
If Wii U had better online functionalities, revolutionary controls or if the title was exclusive to the platform.
