Halo 5 vs. Uncharted 4 vs. Zelda U - Reality check necrobump!

[Metallox]

SocialistSlayer said:

Name	Metacritic	First Week	Lifetime
Halo 5	91	2,300000	8,000,000
Uncharted 4	95	1,600,000	7,100,000
Zelda U	95	1,200.000	4,200,000

halo will be good, but have weaker sales than normal due to xbox one not being as popular. 7.5-8.8 million. meta: 88-92

Uncharted will be huge. perhaps not reaching the score of U2 but close, and will be the best selling. i predict 6.5-8 million. meta: 92-96

Zelda will be massively over rated, it will fail to innovate and modernize anything, it will have the same tired and dated mechanics and tropes as its predessors from the 90's. but reviewers wil give it a pass because its a nintendo game. which are a protected class of games that dont get criticized for being dated on just about everything about their games. it will sell between 3.5-5.5 million . meta: 90-95

I doubt about your Zelda prediction. The linear nature of both Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword was criticised and now Zelda U will be open-world, mainly based on the first game of the series. That's not new, we need to see details about the game first, but the negative aspect of this fatiguing series now is gone, it will do good in Metacritic for instance. I expect something around 94-97.