DerNebel on 10 June 2014
Based on your description of the points I have to say
MS: 3/5 (the show was good, very solid, but it really didn't have any surprises for me)
Sony: 4/5 (the show wasn't necessarily better than MS's, but my expectations for it were alot lower since the internet was really dooming that event, so they definitely exceeded my expectations)
EA: 2/5
Ubisoft: 3/5
